I have a Midi file with 2 tracks but they don't play at the same time. How can I have the 2 tracks at the same time ?
Here is the Midi File
Hope you can help me.
18 comments
Like
Comments (18)
enzocampanella57
May 10, 2020
I used the same file.
Really thank you, it helped me a lot.
Like
visualmusicdesign
May 10, 2020
Ok, glad to at least hear that...
I truly believe this is now fixed in the app - unless you're using a different file from the one you sent me previously (in which case please upload the new file).
I'm not sure which platform you're on - but also double check you're not running the app from a shortcut, or menu, that could possibly be accessing the old version in some way
Like
enzocampanella57
May 10, 2020
Yes but it's maybe just me.
But now I'm using Aria Maestosa and it works so it's ok.
Like
visualmusicdesign
May 10, 2020
I'm testing in Version 1.26 and it's working perfectly now (and most certainly was broken before the update).
Are you 200% sure you are using Version 1.26?
Like
enzocampanella57
May 10, 2020
Nope, I tried with another MIDI file modified with Midi Editor and it still plays the two parts one after the other.
Like
enzocampanella57
May 10, 2020
Yes I ignored the virus.
The two parts play not at the same time but I will retry.
Like
visualmusicdesign
May 10, 2020
Any virus warning regarding the app is incorrect - the app is distributed on the Apple App Stores, which have extremely rigorous code checks... You would just need to find a way to ignore the virus warning and open the app.
I've thoroughly tested with the MIDI you sent in this post - can you please explain more about what you mean by "doesn't work with the MIDI sent in this post"?
Like
enzocampanella57
May 10, 2020
It doesn't work with the MIDI sent in this post and it seems that the file is infected by "IDP.Generic". I don't know what it is but that's what my computer said.
Like
visualmusicdesign
May 10, 2020
This should now be fixed in Version 1.26 - available now for Windows and Android.
The MacOS and iOS update should be available tonight / tomorrow.
Please let me know if everything looks good now?
Like
enzocampanella57
May 09, 2020
Ok. Thank you very much ! And if it's not possible, it's okay, we can use other softwares.
Like
visualmusicdesign
May 09, 2020
I can see how I can write a workaround to deal with these kinds of MIDI files... I think it is possible that the free program, MIDI Editor, is creating an unusual and possibly incorrect file structure.
But I'm sure a lot of users like to use this free software, so I'll try to write the workaround in the next few hours.
Like
enzocampanella57
May 09, 2020
It's a MIDI file recorded on my piano and modified with Midi Editor but I think that there is something strange too.
Like
visualmusicdesign
May 09, 2020
There do seem to be some strange things going on in this MIDI file....
- Can you tell me exactly how the MIDI was created?
Thank you
Like
visualmusicdesign
May 09, 2020
Should be fixed in the next 24 hours.
Like
enzocampanella57
May 09, 2020
Okay, is it possible to tell me when this issue is fixed ? Thank you.
Like
visualmusicdesign
May 09, 2020
I opened using Aria Maestoso and can see both tracks. Not sure why Logic X can't handle this MIDI file... in any case, I'll get to seeing what needs to be fixed in SeeMusic.
Like
enzocampanella57
May 09, 2020
Normally, the file has both hands in it, so I don't really know what to say...
Like
visualmusicdesign
May 09, 2020
Thank you - I'm able to see an issue here that I'll get to fixing today... need to ask a couple questions to clarify -
When I open this MIDI in Logic X, I'm only seeing 1 track with what looks like the right hand. This one is also labeled "Test" - do you have another file that has both hands in it?
I used the same file.
Really thank you, it helped me a lot.
Ok, glad to at least hear that...
I truly believe this is now fixed in the app - unless you're using a different file from the one you sent me previously (in which case please upload the new file).
I'm not sure which platform you're on - but also double check you're not running the app from a shortcut, or menu, that could possibly be accessing the old version in some way
Yes but it's maybe just me.
But now I'm using Aria Maestosa and it works so it's ok.
I'm testing in Version 1.26 and it's working perfectly now (and most certainly was broken before the update).
Are you 200% sure you are using Version 1.26?
Nope, I tried with another MIDI file modified with Midi Editor and it still plays the two parts one after the other.
Yes I ignored the virus.
The two parts play not at the same time but I will retry.
Any virus warning regarding the app is incorrect - the app is distributed on the Apple App Stores, which have extremely rigorous code checks... You would just need to find a way to ignore the virus warning and open the app.
I've thoroughly tested with the MIDI you sent in this post - can you please explain more about what you mean by "doesn't work with the MIDI sent in this post"?
It doesn't work with the MIDI sent in this post and it seems that the file is infected by "IDP.Generic". I don't know what it is but that's what my computer said.
This should now be fixed in Version 1.26 - available now for Windows and Android.
The MacOS and iOS update should be available tonight / tomorrow.
Please let me know if everything looks good now?
Ok. Thank you very much ! And if it's not possible, it's okay, we can use other softwares.
I can see how I can write a workaround to deal with these kinds of MIDI files... I think it is possible that the free program, MIDI Editor, is creating an unusual and possibly incorrect file structure.
But I'm sure a lot of users like to use this free software, so I'll try to write the workaround in the next few hours.
It's a MIDI file recorded on my piano and modified with Midi Editor but I think that there is something strange too.
There do seem to be some strange things going on in this MIDI file....
- Can you tell me exactly how the MIDI was created?
Thank you
Should be fixed in the next 24 hours.
Okay, is it possible to tell me when this issue is fixed ? Thank you.
I opened using Aria Maestoso and can see both tracks. Not sure why Logic X can't handle this MIDI file... in any case, I'll get to seeing what needs to be fixed in SeeMusic.
Normally, the file has both hands in it, so I don't really know what to say...
Thank you - I'm able to see an issue here that I'll get to fixing today... need to ask a couple questions to clarify -
When I open this MIDI in Logic X, I'm only seeing 1 track with what looks like the right hand. This one is also labeled "Test" - do you have another file that has both hands in it?